Local graph node deployment Ganache vs Geth / Rinkeby

[alejoacosta74]

Hi team
We are testing the local deployment of a Graph node.

We are testing Geth/Rinkeby against Ganache, with the same smart contract and same subgraph definition

With Ganache everything works like a charm, but with Geth, the Graph is not able to read the smart contract data and expose it via graphiql.

For comparison, these are the graph logs when running yarn create-local and yarn deploy-local when connected to Geth/Rinkeby:

2021-06-14T15:23:54.915776326Z Jun 14 15:23:54.915 INFO Syncing 50 blocks from Ethereum., code: BlockIngestionLagging, blocks_needed: 50, blocks_behind: 208, latest_block_head: 8763196, current_block_head: 8762988, network_name: rinkeby, component: BlockIngestor
2021-06-14T15:24:16.723574688Z Jun 14 15:24:16.723 INFO Received subgraph_deploy request, params: SubgraphDeployParams { name: SubgraphName("people-rinkeby"), ipfs_hash: SubgraphDeploymentId("QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j"), node_id: None }, component: JsonRpcServer
2021-06-14T15:24:16.723606000Z Jun 14 15:24:16.723 INFO Resolve manifest, link: /ipfs/QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphRegistrar
2021-06-14T15:24:16.726588341Z Jun 14 15:24:16.726 INFO Resolve schema, link: /ipfs/QmVqNxuqcBnD54tqR8WnLLMBNWuHo9Zapp4o56VDQRMjpu, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphRegistrar
2021-06-14T15:24:16.726614040Z Jun 14 15:24:16.726 INFO Resolve data source, source: 8742105, name: PersonRegistry, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphRegistrar
2021-06-14T15:24:16.726624283Z Jun 14 15:24:16.726 INFO Resolve mapping, link: /ipfs/QmfTcK3Fj8Y33Nu734Ku6BsoyTe9R6nV5r6Fk5SYUYzFVC, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphRegistrar
2021-06-14T15:24:16.726642215Z Jun 14 15:24:16.726 INFO Resolve ABI, link: /ipfs/QmXtiRNTEHScJYovV3oiuhY277yurkfW1CXkuHJZpPP28g, name: PersonRegistry, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphRegistrar
2021-06-14T15:24:16.732990007Z Jun 14 15:24:16.732 INFO Set subgraph start block, block_hash: Some(0x73bec154195305919a669d9f64acac80803b52217b43c9a11263bf8f23a13f82), block_number: Some(8742104), subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphRegistrar
2021-06-14T15:24:16.733013703Z Jun 14 15:24:16.732 INFO Graft base, block: None, base: None, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphRegistrar
2021-06-14T15:24:16.800369120Z Jun 14 15:24:16.800 INFO Resolve subgraph files using IPFS, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphAssignmentProvider
2021-06-14T15:24:16.800398541Z Jun 14 15:24:16.800 INFO Resolve manifest, link: /ipfs/QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphAssignmentProvider
2021-06-14T15:24:16.800447538Z Jun 14 15:24:16.800 INFO Resolve schema, link: /ipfs/QmVqNxuqcBnD54tqR8WnLLMBNWuHo9Zapp4o56VDQRMjpu, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphAssignmentProvider
2021-06-14T15:24:16.800540886Z Jun 14 15:24:16.800 INFO Resolve data source, source: 8742105, name: PersonRegistry, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphAssignmentProvider
2021-06-14T15:24:16.800566386Z Jun 14 15:24:16.800 INFO Resolve mapping, link: /ipfs/QmfTcK3Fj8Y33Nu734Ku6BsoyTe9R6nV5r6Fk5SYUYzFVC, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphAssignmentProvider
2021-06-14T15:24:16.800585049Z Jun 14 15:24:16.800 INFO Resolve ABI, link: /ipfs/QmXtiRNTEHScJYovV3oiuhY277yurkfW1CXkuHJZpPP28g, name: PersonRegistry, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphAssignmentProvider
2021-06-14T15:24:16.803219233Z Jun 14 15:24:16.803 INFO Successfully resolved subgraph files using IPFS, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphAssignmentProvider
2021-06-14T15:24:16.803284000Z Jun 14 15:24:16.803 INFO Start subgraph, data_sources: 1, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager
2021-06-14T15:24:16.818276556Z Jun 14 15:24:16.818 INFO Scanning blocks [8742105, 8742105], range_size: 1, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager > BlockStream
2021-06-14T15:24:16.834505551Z Jun 14 15:24:16.834 INFO Scanning blocks [8742106, 8742115], range_size: 10, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager > BlockStream
2021-06-14T15:24:16.846075124Z Jun 14 15:24:16.845 INFO Scanning blocks [8742116, 8742215], range_size: 100, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager > BlockStream
2021-06-14T15:24:16.859986580Z Jun 14 15:24:16.859 INFO Scanning blocks [8742216, 8743215], range_size: 1000, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager > BlockStream
2021-06-14T15:24:16.873997550Z Jun 14 15:24:16.873 INFO Scanning blocks [8743216, 8745215], range_size: 2000, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager > BlockStream
2021-06-14T15:24:16.891289134Z Jun 14 15:24:16.891 INFO Scanning blocks [8745216, 8747215], range_size: 2000, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager > BlockStream
2021-06-14T15:24:16.905543257Z Jun 14 15:24:16.905 INFO Scanning blocks [8747216, 8749215], range_size: 2000, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager > BlockStream
2021-06-14T15:24:16.924323758Z Jun 14 15:24:16.924 INFO Scanning blocks [8749216, 8751215], range_size: 2000, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager > BlockStream
2021-06-14T15:24:17.008039672Z Jun 14 15:24:17.007 INFO Scanning blocks [8751216, 8753215], range_size: 2000, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager > BlockStream
2021-06-14T15:24:17.082806649Z Jun 14 15:24:17.082 INFO Scanning blocks [8753216, 8755215], range_size: 2000, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager > BlockStream
2021-06-14T15:24:17.156182679Z Jun 14 15:24:17.156 INFO Scanning blocks [8755216, 8757215], range_size: 2000, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager > BlockStream
2021-06-14T15:24:17.229658950Z Jun 14 15:24:17.229 INFO Scanning blocks [8757216, 8759215], range_size: 2000, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager > BlockStream
2021-06-14T15:24:17.662199140Z Jun 14 15:24:17.662 INFO Scanning blocks [8759216, 8761215], range_size: 2000, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager > BlockStream
2021-06-14T15:24:17.739730258Z Jun 14 15:24:17.739 INFO Scanning blocks [8761216, 8762938], range_size: 2000, subgraph_id: QmbuRx1zqLqFJ32JQWR4ecLh88PtxkDEsp4x4XLiZitG1j, component: SubgraphInstanceManager > BlockStream
2021-06-14T15:24:19.764686096Z Jun 14 15:24:19.764 INFO Syncing 50 blocks from Ethereum., code: BlockIngestionLagging, blocks_needed: 50, blocks_behind: 210, latest_block_head: 8763198, current_block_head: 8762988, network_name: rinkeby, component: BlockIngestor

[alejoacosta74]

And these are the graph logs when running yarn create-local and yarn deploy-local when connected to Ganache (same smart contract and same subgraph):

2021-06-14T17:38:41.162184324Z Jun 14 17:38:41.162 INFO Received subgraph_create request, params: SubgraphCreateParams { name: SubgraphName("people-ganache") }, component: JsonRpcServer
2021-06-14T17:38:55.808696073Z Jun 14 17:38:55.808 INFO Received subgraph_deploy request, params: SubgraphDeployParams { name: SubgraphName("people-ganache"), ipfs_hash: DeploymentHash("QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR"), node_id: None }, c
omponent: JsonRpcServer
2021-06-14T17:38:55.808726781Z Jun 14 17:38:55.808 INFO Resolve manifest, link: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, sgd: 0, subgraph_id: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, component: SubgraphRegistrar
2021-06-14T17:38:55.811085582Z Jun 14 17:38:55.810 INFO Resolve schema, link: /ipfs/QmVNmtAaWVHp5YaFWiueKqrVTuwuKfdGU4eQpYiVjdmS8S, sgd: 0, subgraph_id: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, component: SubgraphRegistrar
2021-06-14T17:38:55.811112218Z Jun 14 17:38:55.811 INFO Resolve data source, source: 0, name: PersonRegistry, sgd: 0, subgraph_id: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, component: SubgraphRegistrar
2021-06-14T17:38:55.811157805Z Jun 14 17:38:55.811 INFO Resolve mapping, link: /ipfs/QmfTcK3Fj8Y33Nu734Ku6BsoyTe9R6nV5r6Fk5SYUYzFVC, sgd: 0, subgraph_id: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, component: SubgraphRegistrar
2021-06-14T17:38:55.811184029Z Jun 14 17:38:55.811 INFO Resolve ABI, link: /ipfs/QmXtiRNTEHScJYovV3oiuhY277yurkfW1CXkuHJZpPP28g, name: PersonRegistry, sgd: 0, subgraph_id: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, component: SubgraphRegistrar
2021-06-14T17:38:55.814664849Z Jun 14 17:38:55.814 INFO Set subgraph start block, block_hash: None, block_number: None, sgd: 0, subgraph_id: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, component: SubgraphRegistrar
2021-06-14T17:38:55.814687993Z Jun 14 17:38:55.814 INFO Graft base, block: None, base: None, sgd: 0, subgraph_id: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, component: SubgraphRegistrar
2021-06-14T17:38:56.373279207Z Jun 14 17:38:56.373 INFO Resolve subgraph files using IPFS, sgd: 1, subgraph_id: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, component: SubgraphInstanceManager
2021-06-14T17:38:56.373310422Z Jun 14 17:38:56.373 INFO Resolve schema, link: /ipfs/QmVNmtAaWVHp5YaFWiueKqrVTuwuKfdGU4eQpYiVjdmS8S, sgd: 1, subgraph_id: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, component: SubgraphInstanceManager
2021-06-14T17:38:56.373316393Z Jun 14 17:38:56.373 INFO Resolve data source, source: 0, name: PersonRegistry, sgd: 1, subgraph_id: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, component: SubgraphInstanceManager
2021-06-14T17:38:56.373320403Z Jun 14 17:38:56.373 INFO Resolve mapping, link: /ipfs/QmfTcK3Fj8Y33Nu734Ku6BsoyTe9R6nV5r6Fk5SYUYzFVC, sgd: 1, subgraph_id: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, component: SubgraphInstanceManager
2021-06-14T17:38:56.373325739Z Jun 14 17:38:56.373 INFO Resolve ABI, link: /ipfs/QmXtiRNTEHScJYovV3oiuhY277yurkfW1CXkuHJZpPP28g, name: PersonRegistry, sgd: 1, subgraph_id: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, component: SubgraphInstanceManager
2021-06-14T17:38:56.374565857Z Jun 14 17:38:56.374 INFO Successfully resolved subgraph files using IPFS, sgd: 1, subgraph_id: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, component: SubgraphInstanceManager
2021-06-14T17:38:56.374588437Z Jun 14 17:38:56.374 INFO Data source count at start: 1, sgd: 1, subgraph_id: QmbKETWpTxg1sCTB2LbstZwY567dUZqt3tkvNbjSH3hiRR, component: SubgraphInstanceManager
2021-06-14T17:38:56.376193104Z [2021-06-14T17:38:56Z INFO  regalloc]
2021-06-14T17:38:56.376378624Z [2021-06-14T17:38:56Z INFO  regalloc] ================ regalloc.rs: BEGIN function ================
2021-06-14T17:38:56.376404386Z [2021-06-14T17:38:56Z INFO  regalloc] with options: checker: false, algorithm: backtracking (block annotations: false)
2021-06-14T17:38:56.376410339Z [2021-06-14T17:38:56Z INFO  regalloc]
2021-06-14T17:38:56.376414586Z [2021-06-14T17:38:56Z INFO  regalloc]
2021-06-14T17:38:56.376418410Z [2021-06-14T17:38:56Z INFO  regalloc] ================ regalloc.rs: BEGIN function ================
2021-06-14T17:38:56.376422542Z [2021-06-14T17:38:56Z INFO  regalloc] with options: checker: false, algorithm: backtracking (block annotations: false)
2021-06-14T17:38:56.376427347Z [2021-06-14T17:38:56Z INFO  regalloc] using RealRegUniverse:
2021-06-14T17:38:56.376431252Z [2021-06-14T17:38:56Z INFO  regalloc]
2021-06-14T17:38:56.376435126Z [2021-06-14T17:38:56Z INFO  regalloc] ================ regalloc.rs: BEGIN function ================
2021-06-14T17:38:56.376439344Z [2021-06-14T17:38:56Z INFO  regalloc]   class I32(J) at [16 .. 29]: %rsi %rdi %rax %rcx %rdx %r8 %r9 %r10 %r11 %r12* %r13 %r14 %rbx %r15

[alejoacosta74]

As described above, the Graph works as expected with Ganache, and the data is accesible via graphiql.
@azf20 if you can spare a couple of minutes, would you be so kind to shred some light about how to determine the reason why this setup could be working with Ganache and not with Geth/Rinkeby?

Just in case, this is the contract we are targeting on Rinkeby: https://rinkeby.etherscan.io/address/0xe072208c66b37f4f00fabded75cafd5f88fd43dc

[azf20]

Can you share your subgraph manifest? Are you just using event handlers? Looking at both of the logs shared, I actually don't see any events being processed on either setup?

[alejoacosta74]

This subgraph is a clone of the Avatar example, just with a different name. Here you have it:

specVersion: 0.0.2
schema:
  file: ./schema.graphql
dataSources:
  - kind: ethereum/contract
    name: PersonRegistry
    network: rinkeby
    source:
      address: "0xe072208C66B37F4f00fABded75CaFd5F88Fd43dC"
      abi: PersonRegistry
      startBlock: 8742105
    mapping:
      kind: ethereum/events
      apiVersion: 0.0.4
      language: wasm/assemblyscript
      entities:
        - Person
      abis:
        - name: PersonRegistry
          file: ./abis/PersonRegistry.json
      eventHandlers:
        - event: NewPerson(uint256,address,string,string)
          handler: handleNewPerson
        - event: UpdatedPerson(uint256,address,string,string)
          handler: handleUpdatedPerson
      file: ./src/mapping.ts